FREE Subscription The World’s Most Popular Natural Health Newsletter   
How Much Are Drug Companies Really Paying Your Doctor?

According to this fascinating New York Times piece, seven legislatures have passed laws requiring drug companies to disclose how much they've spent on the marketing efforts in their individual states, and an accompanying Journal of the American Medical Association study focuses on two of them (Minnesota and Vermont).

Drugmakers have kept details of the payouts to health care professionals in Vermont private, declaring them "trade secrets." But Minnesota's disclosures are a matter of public record.

Since 1997, when the Minnesota law was passed, drug companies have paid more than 5,500 health care workers in the state at least $57 million; more than 20 percent of the state's physicians received money, and over 100 people received more than $100,000. Ten doctors and one dentist received more than $500,000. Another $40 million was paid to clinics, research centers and other organizations.

Psychiatrists, as a profession, received the most money, followed by doctors who specialize in internal medicine, then cardiologists, endocrinologists and neurologists.

Doctors often received payments in return for delivering lectures about drugs to other doctors. Some sat on the committees that create nationwide guidelines about when to use medicines; a 2002 survey actually found that upwards of 80 percent of the doctors on such panels had financial ties to drug makers. A small number of doctors were being paid to do research.

Studies have shown that doctors who have close financial ties to drug companies tend to prescribe newer, pricier drugs, even if this is not in the best interest of the patients. Few patients are aware of the financial connections between the doctors prescribing drugs and the companies making them.

Journal of the American Medical Association, Vol. 297, No. 11, March 21, 2007: 1216-1223

New York Times March 21, 2007 (Registration Required)

Tuscaloosa News.com March 21, 2007


Dr. Mercola's Comment:

In the United States as a whole, drug companies shell out $4 billion to advertise directly to consumers on the television and print media. But that is small potatoes when it comes to what they spend on marketing to physicians to spread their message that drugs are the answer to all health care problems.

They spend 400 percent more, or $16 billion each year, to directly influence doctors. That is $10,000 for every single physician in the United States. In reality, the average amount is even somewhat higher, since they don't bother to spend much money on doctors who practice natural medicine and won't prescribe their toxic drugs.

I can assure you they haven't spent a wooden nickel on me this century, as I stopped seeing drug reps in the last century.

Why do they spend so much?

Please understand that drug companies are not stupid. Like any smart corporation they invest in this marketing because it works.

They make far more money as a result of their $16-billion investment in physician marketing. A Harvard Business School professional quoted in the Times echoed my exact sentiments about the all-too-cozy relationship between the drug companies and practitioners of conventional medicine:

"A doctor who represents a pharmaceutical company will tend to see the data in a slightly more positive light and as a result will overprescribe that company's drugs. When honest human beings have a vested stake in seeing the world in a particular way, they're incapable of objectivity and independence."

The same rationale also applies, unfortunately, to the sad state of drug safety in America, often trumped by ridiculous marketing ploys like giveaways and, when all else fails, the low art of disease mongering.

Meanwhile, the sad fact of the matter is, most of the drugs being prescribed by these compromised doctors are useless at best and outright dangerous at worst. And don't expect the hobbled, seriously compromised FDA to ever take on the drug companies. Remember, as it's currently configured, the FDA works in the best interests of the multi-national drug manufacturers, and not you!

Related Articles:




Did you find this article interesting?
Article's Comment     ( 42 Comments )
 
 
 +6 Points           
 
Author of the Article
BY Rett   
  
[ Joined on 11/06 ]
[ Posted on April 07, 2007 ]
Post Reply
Since my heart attack in late 2001, I've had two doctors send me certified letters giving me 30 days to find another doctor because I exercized my Florida Patients' Bill of Rights by refusing any treatments I felt were unnecessary or dangerous, ie drugs, which is all they cared to talk about.  In their minds, I needed blood thinners, statins, low dose aspiring, something to keep my BS in check. Methotrexate for psoriatic arthritis.  Nothing was said by them  about how I could turn it all around with nutritional approaches.  I had to research that all by my little ole self.  That first doctor wanted to know my education level that gave me the idea that I could diagnose and "treat" myself.  He got defensive when I said no to his drug protocol.  Food is my medicine and medicine is my food now.  :) I even found a farm that grows certified organic food and has real milk just up the road from me.  Thank you, Father, from whom all blessings flow.  Hugs from Florida
 

 +1 Points           
 
Author of the Article
BY justdogtired   
  
[ Joined on 04/07 ]
Author of the Article [ Posted on April 07, 2007 ]
 
I wish my dad was as wise as you!  He blindly follows all his doctor's recommendations, and takes all the drugs he prescribes...and continues to eat slop!  I've tried to educate him on this stuff, but he doesn 't care to listen.  My mom has high cholesterol and tells her doctor she doesn't want to take medication, that she'll lower it naturally...which she has done several times...but he gets frustrated with her and pressures her...so she caves.  I went to the doctor for a physical and found my cholesterol number was a little higher than the average person, and the doctor immediately wanted to prescribe medicine even though the overall ratio was in a normal range... I refused, of course.  Since then, I quit drinking alcohol, grains that are not sprouted, and sugar, and began eating food as close to it's natural state as possible...I've lost 30 pounds...haven't been this small since my early 20's. I feel great!!!  I give the glory to God for removing the scales from my eyes.  I pray the same for everyone.

            
 
Author of the Article
BY Miss Health Chick   
  
[ Joined on 11/06 ]
Author of the Article [ Posted on April 05, 2008 ]
 
Right on!

 
 +6 Points           
 
Author of the Article
BY PPARGammaGirl   
  
[ Joined on 06/06 ]
[ Posted on March 21, 2007 ]
Post Reply
 

It’s not just what they get in “gifts” (bribes) but what goes into Continuing Medical Education (CME). Billions go into this and it is not counted in their Marketing budget. Medscape and other behemoths all provide FREE CME to doctors – not because they are philanthropic idealists and all-round lovely chaps, but because big Pharma pays them to. A huge amount of revenue from industry goes to these sites, now I just wonder, just a slight suspicion, whether this relationship might affect their content?

Of course it does. Just go to Medscape’s site and look up “insomnia” – it’s now a deadly disease apparently, and requires the rigorous application of “novel therapeutic treatments” (expensive toxic muck), blah, blah….plug new drug…blah, blah…plug new drug.

It’s not CME, it’s a high-level sales pitch that would shame a Kirby vacuum cleaner salesman!

 

 -1 Points           
 
Author of the Article
BY Area51   
  
[ Joined on 12/06 ]
Author of the Article [ Posted on April 09, 2007 ]
 
I'm a little confused here. Do doctors get paid any money/bonuses for each presciption that they write? Or do they just get a general amount and free gifts, etc. from Pharma companies? 

The reason why I am asking is cause last week on the Dr.Phil show, last season's "The Bachelor" who happens to be an ER doctor, Dr.Stork, was on the show. There was a woman on the show who had a question for Dr.Sork. She had a bone density test done which showed that she had signs of osteoporosis. Her doctor wanted her to take the drug Fosamax but she so far has refused, one, because she is suspicious of her doctor's motive for prescribing her the drug, (money, etc.). And two, she researched the drug and she doesn't feel that the drug treats the cause or will fix the problem. She exercises and weight trains and feels that weight training is more effective in building bone density but that her doctor never even discussed exercise as an option or important for bone health. 

So in the end, Dr.Stork told her that he advises her to take the drug and that contrary to what people may have heard, doctors do NOT make any money for prescribing drugs or get any kickbacks from drug companies. So if what he said is not true, then I find that irresponsible and misleading for him to say on national Television. Can someone clearify this?


 
 +3 Points